Google Lighthouse vs Core Web Vitals

November 4, 2021
0 minute read

From the variety of ways to measure your website’s performance and user experience, Google Lighthouse and Core Web Vitals stand out as two of the most well-known. This article takes a deep dive into comparing the two approaches to help you understand what they are, how they differ, and when to use them. 

Download Your Lighthouse VS Core Web Vitals Cheatsheet >>

Lighthouse and Core Web Vitals: What Are They? 

Lighthouse is a Google tool that audits the performance, accessibility, SEO, and other best practice quality indicators of your web pages from within a fixed test environment. Based on the audits and checks it carries out, Lighthouse generates a report that you can use to assess performance and improve your web pages. 


The Lighthouse testing environment simulates what it would be like to visit your website on a slower 3G Internet connection using a mobile device. Globally, more than 90 percent of the world’s population has access to a mobile broadband network, however, 8.5 percent of that figure still uses 3G networks. This speed constraint makes any on-site issues that slow pages down stand out while also reflecting real-world conditions for many users visiting your site. 


Lighthouse also uses a fixed CPU speed to simulate the experience of visiting your website. The current device used is a Moto G4, which is not as powerful as today’s top-tier smartphones. The use of a slightly underpowered CPU in the testing environment reflects the fact that many visitors to your site use older mobile devices. 


Core Web Vitals are a set of three metrics that attempt to measure and summarize the overall user experience of visiting your web pages. These metrics use field data, which contrasts with the controlled testing environment simulated by the Lighthouse tool. This field data is real-world data anonymously sent to Google from actual users when they visit a specific page. 


It’s important to understand that Core Web Vitals became a Google ranking factor in August 2021. The score you get on these metrics can make a difference in how prominently you appear within Google’s own search engine results pages for your targeted search queries. 


Core Web Vitals are not limited to raw speed — here are the three specific areas of user experience that they cover:


  • Loading time: How long does it take for the page to finish loading?
  • Interactivity: How quickly does your page respond after the user’s first interaction with it?
  • Visual Stability: How stable is your web page within users’ browsers?


Pro tip: You should rely on Core Web Vitals data as much as possible to assess performance and user experience because it’s real-world aggregated data, not point-in-time data based on a controlled set of lab conditions. 


Download Your Lighthouse VS Core Web Vitals Cheatsheet >>

Lighthouse and Core Web Vitals: Metrics and Optimal Thresholds 

So, what are the actual metrics (and their optimal thresholds) used within these two different approaches to measuring performance and user experience?

 











Lighthouse


The Lighthouse Performance report uses six different metrics as follows:


1) Largest Contentful Paint (LCP): a measure of your page’s loading time that checks how long it takes for the largest above the fold element (image, text, etc) to load. Above the fold means that the metric only considers what appears on the page without scrolling down. 


Optimal threshold: Less than 2.5 seconds

2) Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS): measures the visual stability of a page load by focusing on unexpected layout shifts not caused by a user interaction. The actual CLS calculation multiplies together two measures of movement: impact fraction and distance fraction. The lower the calculated score, the better visual stability your page has. 


Sometimes when a page loads, elements shift around unexpectedly and frustrate users. For example, you might load a page and start reading a paragraph, only for an image to load that pushes the paragraph down the page. Specifying image dimensions is one way to improve your CLS scores (among several other ways). 


Optimal threshold: Less than 0.1

3) Total Blocking Time (TBT): measures the total amount of time that a page is blocked from responding to user input. These inputs include mouse clicks or keyboard strokes. 


Optimal threshold: Less than 200 milliseconds

4) First Contentful Paint (FCP): this is the time taken until the first piece of content loads on the page. The content must come from the page’s DOM (Document Object Model). The DOM includes standard page content like images and text. 


Optimal threshold: Less than 1.8 seconds

5) Speed Index: measures the entire loading process for the visual parts of a web page by capturing a video of the page loading and checking the difference between frames. The total duration essentially measures how long it takes to go from blank screen to complete page. 


Optimal threshold: Less than 3.4 seconds

6) TIme to Interactive: measures how long the page takes to become fully interactive so that it reliably and rapidly responds to user inputs. 


Optimal threshold: Less than 0.1

 






Core Web Vitals


Two of the three Core Web Vital metrics are the same LCP and CLS measures as Lighthouse uses (and they have the same optimal thresholds). The third metric in Core Web Vitals is First Input Delay (FID), which measures the interactivity and responsiveness of a page. The calculation takes the time from the user’s first interaction, such as clicking a button, until the browser can start responding to that interaction. 


Remember, Lighthouse uses simulated lab data to generate reports while Core Web Vitals scores are based on real user data. FID is only measurable using real-world data because it depends on an actual user’s action. Lighthouse uses the Total Blocking Time metric as a proxy for FID’s value. 

Download Your Lighthouse VS Core Web Vitals Cheatsheet >>

Lighthouse and Core Web Vitals: Performance Scoring 

Lighthouse

As you can see from the Lighthouse scoring calculator, the report uses a weighted average calculation to provide you with a total Performance score. The LCP and TBT metrics are particularly heavily weighted in this calculation. 


By looking at the distribution of all metric scores across every test performed, Lighthouse gauges where your particular page falls in that distribution. This enables Lighthouse to convert raw metric scores into a standard 0-100 value. A good Lighthouse score for any individual performance metric or for the total weighted average performance score is anything above 90.

 

Core Web Vitals


The real-world focus of Core Web Vitals makes the performance scoring a bit simpler than Lighthouse. For you to score well in any of the three metrics, you must get a “Good” score in that metric for 75 percent of visitors to your page. If you score “Good” on all three metrics, you pass the Core Web Vitals assessment. The definition of “Good” is that a metric’s score falls within the previously outlined optimal threshold. 


The scores are calculated using aggregated field data from many users over a 28-day period. This 28-day period is important to bear in mind because if you score badly and then make some improvements, you’ll need to wait a while for Google to pick those improvements up. 

Download Your Lighthouse VS Core Web Vitals Cheatsheet >>

Lighthouse and Core Web Vitals: Performance Scoring 

Lighthouse


If you want to get a Lighthouse report, the most user-friendly ways are to use the Lighthouse extension for your Chrome web browser or to simply visit Google's Web Dev Portal and enter your URL. Other options include Chrome Dev Tools, Page Speed Insights, and using the command line. 


Core Web Vitals


A number of tools measure Core Web Vitals, including Chrome User Experience


Report (cRUX), Google Search Console, and PageSpeed Insights. The quickest and simplest way to check any URL’s Core Web Vitals is through PageSpeed Insights. 


Duda’s Core Web Vital Achievements 

Among all website builders, Duda leads the way in ensuring our users’ websites score consistently well on Core Web Vitals. Given that Core Web Vitals are a ranking factor in Google search results, it’s important that your website or your clients’ websites score well in these metrics. Good Core Web Vitals scores are also vital from a conversion standpoint — customers prefer to do business with sites that provide a solid performance and strong user experience. 


Since Core Web Vitals became a ranking factor, Duda leads the way with the highest proportion of sites on our platform scoring “Good” versus competitors such as WordPress, Drupal, Wix, and Squarespace. Some competitors (no names mentioned) omit Duda from their Data Studio comparison graphs in an attempt to make it look like they are industry leaders. Pro tip: if you want the full picture, visit this Google Data Studio link and see how all platforms perform against each other.

Download Your Lighthouse VS Core Web Vitals Cheatsheet >>


Did you find this article interesting?


Thanks for the feedback!
A computer screen with a graph on it and a purple background.
By Santi Clarke April 24, 2025
Learn how platform ecosystems drive revenue and why they are essential for the growth of SaaS businesses.
By Santi Clarke April 24, 2025
One of the greatest challenges for SaaS platforms is keeping users engaged long-term. The term “stickiness” refers to a product's ability to retain users and make them want to return. In the context of SaaS platforms, creating a sticky product means that users consistently find value, experience seamless interactions, and continue using the product over time. The following are 7 practical strategies you can take to improve the stickiness of your SaaS solution. 1. Offer websites that help customers build their digital presence One of the most effective ways to make your SaaS platform sticky is by offering websites to your users. Many businesses today need an online presence, and by providing a platform where your customers can easily build and manage their websites, you increase their reliance on your product. When you offer users a website-building solution, you’re helping them create something foundational to their business. Websites, in this case, aren’t just a tool—they become a part of their identity and brand. This deepens their engagement with your platform, as they need your product to maintain and update their site, ultimately making them less likely to churn. Plus, websites naturally encourage frequent updates, content creation, and customer interactions, which means your users will return to your platform regularly. When you can give your users the tools to create something so essential to their business, you make them more dependent on your platform. This creates a higher barrier to exit, as migrating a fully built website to another service is no small task. In fact, websites are some of the stickiest products you can sell, so adding them to your product portfolio can be one of the best decisions you can to keep your customers using your technology for the long haul. 2. Deliver continuous value through product innovation The key to keeping users coming back to your SaaS platform is ensuring that they consistently see value in it. This means not only meeting their immediate needs but also evolving to address their growing demands. Constant product innovation is essential for keeping your users satisfied and invested in your platform. One way to achieve this is through regular updates that add new features or improvements based on user feedback. A SaaS platform that evolves with its users will keep them engaged longer, making it harder for competitors to steal their attention. Encourage user feedback and prioritize updates that create tangible improvements. This creates an ongoing relationship with your users, which boosts stickiness. 3. Offer a multi-product solution Another powerful way to increase your platform’s stickiness is by offering a suite of products or features that integrate well together. When your users adopt multiple products, they are more likely to stay because they become embedded in your ecosystem. The benefits of this strategy are clear. Research shows that once users adopt more than one product, especially when they integrate >4 tools into their workflow, their likelihood of churn decreases significantly. This happens because the more a user integrates into your suite of products, the harder it is for them to switch to a competitor. These users have invested time in learning your ecosystem and rely on it for their day-to-day operations, making it much harder for them to make the switch. 4. Create a personal connection with your users Human connection is one of the most powerful drivers of user retention. People don’t want to feel like they’re using a cold, faceless platform. By offering exceptional customer support, personalized communication, and community engagement, you build a relationship with your users that goes beyond the product itself. Make sure your support team is responsive, knowledgeable, and empathetic. You can also consider offering tailored onboarding experiences to ensure users understand how to make the most of your platform. When users feel like their success matters to you, they are more likely to remain loyal. 5. Leverage data to personalize the user experience Using data to drive personalization is another strategy that can significantly increase the stickiness of your platform. By tracking user behavior and usage patterns, you can tailor the experience to each individual user’s needs. This could mean recommending features they haven’t yet explored or sending them reminders about tools they may not be fully utilizing. Personalization gives users the feeling that the platform was designed specifically for them, making it harder to walk away from. By demonstrating that you understand their unique needs, you can build a stronger connection and ultimately increase retention rates. 6. Focus on seamless integrations and API capabilities To further increase stickiness, consider expanding your product’s ability to integrate with other tools your users already rely on. Whether it’s email marketing software, CRM systems, or social media management tools, seamless integrations add tremendous value by making it easier for users to incorporate your platform into their existing workflows. The more your product can work in tandem with other popular tools, the more indispensable it becomes. In fact, users who depend on integrations are less likely to churn since their entire ecosystem is tied to your platform’s functionality. 7. Encourage user advocacy and community building User advocacy is another powerful tool in building a sticky product. When users feel a sense of community or even ownership over the platform, they become your most passionate promoters. Encourage your users to share their success stories, join community forums, or contribute to product development through beta testing or feedback loops. A thriving user community not only increases user engagement but also creates a sense of loyalty. When users are part of something larger than themselves, they are more likely to remain committed to your platform, reducing churn and increasing lifetime value. Create deep, lasting customer relationships Making your SaaS platform sticky is all about creating a deep, lasting connection with your users. This requires building a platform that continuously delivers value, creating a seamless and personalized experience, and integrating features that keep users coming back. By focusing on product innovation, offering a multi-product ecosystem, and fostering strong user relationships, you’ll be well on your way to reducing churn and boosting user retention. Stickiness isn’t just a nice-to-have; it’s essential for long-term success. Focus on creating a platform that users can’t imagine living without, and you’ll see them stick around for the long haul.
By Shawn Davis April 24, 2025
Your team is likely pretty familiar with the products they built, but what about the ones they didn’t? Integrated tools can throw a wrench into your support operations, but they don’t have to.
Show More

Latest posts